First Bank of Pizza | Experience the Best Pizza in Juliaetta!

Overview

Nestled in the heart of Juliaetta, Idaho, First Bank of Pizza transforms the charm of a historic 1910 bank into a warm, inviting space where great pizza and friendly service meet. This unique setting is more than just a backdrop—it enhances the dining experience, blending nostalgia with modern comfort to create a spot that welcomes families, locals, and travelers alike.

The star of the menu is undoubtedly their pizza. Whether you opt for the classic pepperoni, the tangy Hawaiian with Canadian bacon and pineapple, or a simple yet satisfying cheese pie, each pizza arrives with a crisp, golden crust and generous toppings. The crust’s crunch is a frequent highlight, praised for balancing perfectly with the rich, flavorful ingredients. For those who enjoy customizing their meal, there are options to build your own pizza with a choice of toppings, allowing for personalized twists on traditional flavors.

Beyond pizza, First Bank of Pizza caters well to the cravings of all diners. Fresh salads offer a crisp counterpoint to the heartier dishes, while the dessert selection dazzles with house-made sweets crafted from scratch. Fans of sweets will find an array of cookies, cupcakes, and pie bars, as well as inventive ice cream flavors rotated regularly, offering something new on every visit. The Brownie Sundae and other decadent treats complement the savory offerings beautifully, making it a go-to spot for those with a sweet tooth.

The owners contribute significantly to the warm atmosphere. Reviews highlight their kindness and dedication, reflecting in the spotless, welcoming environment and the thoughtful touches like changing flowers at the entrance. Their commitment breathes life into this small-town gem, creating a community hub where every detail feels intentional and every guest feels valued.

Whether you are dropping in for a quick, piping-hot pizza or settling in with a milkshake and dessert, First Bank of Pizza’s blend of rich flavors, historic character, and personal touch make it a memorable destination. It’s a place where tradition meets creativity, served with a smile in a space that feels like home. Family-friendly yet appealing to all, it stands out in Juliaetta as a must-visit for pizza lovers and those seeking a genuine local experience.

Amenities & Services

Popular for

Dinner

Solo dining

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Comfort food

Atmosphere

Casual

Historic

What Customers Say

Sonja Stebbins

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Excellent pizza ... the crust was crispy and toppings generous. The owners were very friendly.

Kari Heistand

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Great pizza with especially good crust, cool old 1910 bank but with updates that made it inviting and clean, also nice people. Several ice cream flavors. A nice change after some other places we’ve tried on this trip!

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Nice pizza place good Hawaiian pizza. interesting how it used to be a bank

Bailey Worthey

Dec 11,2025

5/5

The people are very kind ! The pastry case always has something new and delicious every visit (always worth a try). The ice cream case has new flavors drifting in and out making a summer stop by always worth it. The pizza is a lovely golden color with plenty of toppings to follow. With great options of building your own with three toppings of your choice, to putting ur own twist on a pizza bank staple. Along with having a wonderful options for take n bakes ! This place has really added to this small town. Very family friendly and everything in between ! The new owners are very kind and have put in lots of hard work, and it truly shows. Also the flowers outside are beautiful giving a great greetings before entering this historical building ! I definitely recommend this place to anyone who loves a great pizza and environment !

Georgia Savell

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Omgosh this place is so good. With fresh flying pizzas served up piping hot. So many selections and willing to just about any combo you can think of. Nora does amazing specials to keep you on the edge of your seat. And let me tell you this is the A++ stop for a sweet tooth. She makes from scratch everything from cookies, cinnamon rolls, cupcakes, cakes, and pie bars. She also offers hand scooped ice cream 8 flavors on deck at all times. She makes rockin milk shakes and banana splits even. So if your near Juliaetta or Kendrick c'mon in Thursday- Sunday and give her a try!

TIM ODIEE

Dec 11,2025

5/5

I am a meat and potatoes type of guy. I ventured out of my comfort zone and got pizza. The pizza I ordered was the all meat but customized with no salami and add tomatoes (cooked). OMG amazing… I will do that again. … I did it again and Amazing again. Cindy commented that it looks great. It does look great but it also tastes great and I started eating before I thought of a picture… maybe next time..,

Sid Lloyd

Dec 11,2025

5/5

So we stopped in here once about ten years ago. Back then I could say with confidence it was the Worst. Pizza. Ever. I am happy to say that it is under new ownership, has been completely redecorated, (adorable now) and the pizza now is quite good. Also, the pastries are AMAZING! The should. The owner trained at a Colorado culinary school in baking and it shows! I first tried a mini Pizza Pretzel. This was a small, affordable (only $2.50) baked pretzel with cheese and pepperoni on it served with a side of marinara sauce. The sauce had a bright fresh taste which perfectly complemented the pretzel. You could make a darn good meal with just a couple of these. We then split a pre-boxed caesar salad. Large portion size with plenty of excellent dressing. For our main course we ordered the "On the Veg of Your Seat" pizza which was an all veggie tomato sauce, cheese, sautéed sweet mild onion, bell pepper, black olive, and mushroom pie. The crust was thin and crispy and golden brown. We enjoyed the crunch of the crust and there was the optimal amount of cheese. We ordered a 16" pizza pie and could only eat half. But enough of the pizza, let's talk PASTRY! We got the banana vanilla cupcake. Start with a yummy banana bread cupcake, add a banana cream pudding core, and top it off with an incredibly smooth vanilla icing and put a vanilla wafer on the tippy-top. My goodness. It was GOOD! This is going to be a regular stop from now on!